Home > All, General Rants, Politics > Bread and Circuses and Anonymous

Bread and Circuses and Anonymous

Lisa Vaas has an interesting post on the Sophos Naked Security blog (and of course on Graham Cluley’s, Paul Ducklin’s, SophosLabs’, and Chester Wisniewski’s own blogs – call it saturation marketing). She questions the effectiveness of the Anonymous ‘bullying’ campaigns, especially against companies like Sony.

She is right to make the question. Anonymous claims to be fighting for democracy; but if it alienates the population, it will be defeated by democracy. For Anonymous to win, it has a fine line to tread; it will need all the political skills of its enemies to take the people with it.

Lisa Vaas’ own comments illustrate the problem, She says, very bluntly,

SOPA is an affront to the Internet.

But what does she suggest to prevent this affront?

Anonymous, back off. Let consumers handle this, and let us do it without bullying.

Politically, this is a shockingly naive statement from an intelligent lady.

Bread and circuses have been used since our earliest political systems to appease the public. It is particularly relevant to this situation: bread is government and circuses is the entertainment industry; and together they represent the unholy alliance that is driving SOPA in America, ACTA around the world, and so many other restrictive, controlling and censoring laws.

This is the problem faced by Anonymous. How can it fight for freedom without appearing to be taking away the bread and circuses fed to us to keep us quiet and happy and docile. I hope Anonymous succeeds. I hope it grows up and realises that the stakes are enormous. The stakes are freedom itself. It is, along with the other rebels of the Internet such as Wikileaks and organizations like CCC our best hope. But it has to take the people with it. In the end, only people power can make governments realise that they are our servants and not our masters.

Anonymous bullies Sony and Nintendo over SOPA support

About these ads
Categories: All, General Rants, Politics
  1. Lisa Vaas
    January 4, 2012 at 9:51 pm

    I agree, Kevin—I hope Anonymous succeeds as well. I do have qualms about Anonymous sticking it to random people in the companies it targets, though. Does every potential victim of doxing really have the power to change Sony’s stance on the issue? I doubt it. But I’m glad you took me to task on this, because I did rush through without coming up with anything useful vis-a-vis alternative means of stopping SOPA. One would hope that making noise to the powers that be in Washington will stop the bad act, but I don’t know that I have much faith in legislators to heed the electorate as opposed to kowtowing to as you put it, the lucrative bread and circus show. Short of legislators doing the right thing, in my heart of hearts I’m cheering for the plot of Google et al. to conduct an anti-SOPA blackout. That might grab some attention. What else? You tell me. Do you really think Sony and other companies would be intimidated by threatened Anonymous action? Intimidated, yes, but intimidated to the extent of dropping support for legislation that adds so much to their bottom line? I don’t see it.

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 137 other followers